Seven reasons for the impossibility to create a universal definition of life

Vladimír Vodička

Abstract


Although life and questions connected with its definition among traditional philosophical topics, at the beginning of the twenty-first century and after roughly two and a half thousand years of philosophical tradition no satisfactory definition of life is at one´s disposal. Though difficulties bond up with life definition don´t accompany philosophy alone, but also almost all fields touched by this topic. Causes of this state of affairs can be viewed as a combination of several complementary connected facts. Those facts are in the text stated as reasons against the possibility of creating universal definition of life and apply here one by one to the origin of life a postulated boarder line between life and nonlife, evolution of life and its variedness, multiplicity of definitions of life and still going discoveries of new organisms, philosophical tradition and lack of clarity of concepts, evolution of life as a historical process, critique of definitions of life from the point of view of „sample one“ and reflection of the concept life by conceptual analysis. Particular sources are about to be analyzed from the point of philosophy of biology with care for philosophical tradition, to questions linked with life and its selected definitions, to actual findings and explorations focused on life and possible contribution of philosophy to the endeavor of finding definition of life as such. Ground of proposed text is naturalism, physicalism and reductionism.


Keywords


life, definition, philosophy, science, philosophy of biology, evolution, species, organism

https://doi.org/10.5817/pf15-3-1001

Full Text:

PDF (Czech)

References

Show references Hide references

AKKERHUIS, Gerard Jagers op, 2011. Explaining the Origin of Life is not Enough for a Definition of Life. Foundations of Science [online]. 1.11., roč. 16, č. 4, s. 327–329 [vid. 1. září 2014]. ISSN 1233-1821, 1572-8471. Dostupné z: doi:10.1007/s10699-010-9209-4

ATRAN, S., 1998. Folk biology and the anthropology of science: cognitive universals and cultural particulars. The Behavioral and Brain Sciences. 8., roč. 21, č. 4, s. 547–569; discussion 569–609. ISSN 0140-525X.

ATRAN, Scott, 1999. Folkbiology. Cambridge, Mass: The MIT Press. ISBN 9780262631921.

BAGGINI, Julian, 2010. The Philosopher’s Toolkit: A Compendium of Philosophical Concepts and Methods. 2nd edition. Oxford ; Malden, Mass: Wiley-Blackwell. ISBN 9781405190183.

BASHOUR, Bana a Hans D. MULLER, 2013. Contemporary Philosophical Naturalism and Its Implications. 1st edition. New York: Routledge. ISBN 9780415813099.

BEDAU, Mark A., 2007. Artificial Life. In: Matthen MOHAN, Christopher STEPHENS, Dov M GABBAY, Paul THAGARD a John WOODS, ed. Philosophy of Biology. Amsterdam: North-Holland, s. 585–603.

BEDAU, Mark A., 2008. What is Life? In: Sarkar SAHOTRA a PLUTYNSKI, ANYA, ed. A Companion to the Philosophy of Biology. Oxford: Blackwell, s. 455–471.

BEDAU, Mark A., 2012. Introduction to philosophical problems about life. Synthese [online]. 1.3., roč. 185, č. 1, s. 1–3 [vid. 31. srpen 2014]. ISSN 0039-7857, 1573-0964. Dostupné z: doi:10.1007/s11229-011-9872-1

BEDAU, Mark A., 2014. The nature of life. In: Steven LUPER, ed. The Cambridge Companion to Life and Death. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, s. 13–29.

BERKOWITZ, Jacob, 2012. The Stardust Revolution: The New Story of Our Origin in the Stars. Amherst, N.Y: Prometheus Books. ISBN 9781616145491.

CLELAND, Carol E., 2013. Is a General Theory of Life Possible? Seeking the Nature of Life in the Context of a Single Example. Biological Theory [online]. 1.6., roč. 7, č. 4, s. 368–379 [vid. 31. srpen 2014]. ISSN 1555-5542, 1555-5550. Dostupné z: doi:10.1007/s13752-012-0045-3

CLELAND, Carol E. a Christopher F. CHYBA, 2002. Defining „life". Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere: The Journal of the International Society for the Study of the Origin of Life. 8., roč. 32, č. 4, s. 387–393. ISSN 0169-6149.

CLELAND, Carol E. a Michael ZERELLA, 2013. What Is Life? In: Kostas KAMPOURAKIS, ed. The Philosophy of Biology - A Companion for Educators. New York: Springer, s. 31–48.

DALY, Christopher, 2010. An Introduction to Philosophical Methods. 1st edition. Peterborough, Ont.: Breakwater Books. ISBN 9781551119342.

DAWKINS, Richard, 2010. The Greatest Show on Earth: The Evidence for Evolution. Reprint edition. New York: Free Press. ISBN 9781416594796.

DESCARTES, René, 1677. L’homme, et la formation du foetus [online]. Paris: Theodore Girard. Dostupné z: https://archive.org/details/lhommeetlaformat00desc

GAYON, Jean, 2010. Defining Life: Synthesis and Conclusions. Origins of Life and Evolution of Biospheres [online]. 1.4., roč. 40, č. 2, s. 231–244 [vid. 31. srpen 2014]. ISSN 0169-6149, 1573-0875. Dostupné z: doi:10.1007/s11084-010-9204-3

GODFREY-SMITH, Peter, 2007. Conditions for Evolution by Natural Selection. Journal of Philosophy. roč. CIV, č. 10, s. 489–516.

GOULD, Stephen Jay, 1990. Wonderful Life: The Burgess Shale and the Nature of History. B.m.: Norton.

HALDANE, John B. S., 1998. What Is Life? In: Michael RUSE, ed. Philosophy of Biology. New York: Prometheus Books, s. 32–34.

HANCZYC, Martin M., 2011. Structure and the Synthesis of Life. Architectural Design [online]. 1.3., roč. 81, č. 2, s. 26–33 [vid. 2. září 2014]. ISSN 1554-2769. Dostupné z: doi:10.1002/ad.1209

HULL, David L, 1974. Organicism and Reductionism. In: Philosophy of Biological Science. New Jersey: Prentice Hall, s. 125–141.

HUXLEY, Thomas Henry, 1870. On the Physical Basis of Life [online]. New Haven: Charles C. Chatfield & Co. [vid. 31. srpen 2014]. Dostupné z: http://books.google.com/books/about/ON_THE_PHYSICAL_BASIS_OF_LIFE.html?hl=cs&id=CM4ekdbcco4C

CHYBA, C. F. a G. D. MCDONALD, 1995. The origin of life in the solar system: current issues. Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences [online]. roč. 23, s. 215–249. ISSN 0084-6597. Dostupné z: doi:10.1146/annurev.ea.23.050195.001243

INAGAKI, Kayoko a Giyoo HATANO, 1996. Young Children’s Recognition of Commonalities between Animals and Plants. Child Development [online]. 12., roč. 67, č. 6, s. 2823 [vid. 3. září 2014]. ISSN 00093920. Dostupné z: doi:10.2307/1131754

KANT, Immanuel, 1724-1804, 1975. Kritika soudnosti. Praha: Odeon.

KELLER, Fox Evelyn, 2003. Synthetic Biology Redux - Computer Simulatin and Artificial Life. In: Making Sense of Life. Explaining Biological Development with Models, Metaphors, and Machines. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, s. 265–294.

KHALIDI, Muhammad Ali, 2013. Natural Categories and Human Kinds: Classification in the Natural and Social Sciences. Cambridge ; New York: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9781107012745.

KLEIN, Harold P., 1979. The Viking mission and the search for life on Mars. Reviews of Geophysics [online]. 1.10., roč. 17, č. 7, s. 1655–1662 [vid. 3. září 2014]. ISSN 1944-9208. Dostupné z: doi:10.1029/RG017i007p01655

KLEIN, Harold P., Joshua LEDERBERG, Alexander RICH, Norman H. HOROWITZ, Vance I. OYAMA a Gilbert V. LEVIN, 1976. The Viking Mission search for life on Mars. Nature[online]. 1.7., roč. 262, č. 5563, s. 24–27 [vid. 3. září 2014]. Dostupné z: doi:10.1038/262024a0

LÓPEZ, Alejandro, Scott ATRAN, John D. COLEY, Douglas L. MEDIN a Edward E. SMITH, 1997. The Tree of Life: Universal and Cultural Features of Folkbiological Taxonomies and Inductions. Cognitive Psychology [online]. 4., roč. 32, č. 3, s. 251–295 [vid. 3. září 2014]. ISSN 0010-0285. Dostupné z: doi:10.1006/cogp.1997.0651

MACHERY, Edouard, 2012. Why I stopped worrying about the definition of life... and why you should as well. Synthese [online]. 1.3., roč. 185, č. 1, s. 145–164 [vid. 3. září 2014]. ISSN 0039-7857, 1573-0964. Dostupné z: doi:10.1007/s11229-011-9880-1

MAYR, Ernst, 1985. The Growth of Biological Thought: Diversity, Evolution, and Inheritance. Cambridge, Mass.: Belknap Press. ISBN 9780674364462.

MOJZSIS, S. J., G. ARRHENIUS, K. D. MCKEEGAN, T. M. HARRISON, A. P. NUTMAN a C. R. FRIEND, 1996. Evidence for life on Earth before 3,800 million years ago. Nature [online]. 7.11., roč. 384, č. 6604, s. 55–59. ISSN 0028-0836. Dostupné z: doi:10.1038/384055a0

MOREIRA, David a Purificación LÓPEZ-GARCÍA, 2009. Ten reasons to exclude viruses from the tree of life. Nature Reviews Microbiology [online]. 4., roč. 7, č. 4, s. 306–311 [vid. 2. září 2014]. ISSN 1740-1526. Dostupné z: doi:10.1038/nrmicro2108

POIRIER, Bill, 2014. A Conceptual Guide to Thermodynamics. 1st edition. Chichester, West Sussex ; Hoboken, NJ: Wiley. ISBN 9781118840535.

POPA, Radu, 2004. B Chronology of Definitions and Interpretations of Life. In: Between Necessity and Probability. New York: Springer.

PROSS, Addy, 2009. Seeking the chemical roots of darwinism: bridging between chemistry and biology. Chemistry (Weinheim an Der Bergstrasse, Germany) [online]. 24.8., roč. 15, č. 34, s. 8374–8381. ISSN 1521-3765. Dostupné z: doi:10.1002/chem.200900805

PROSS, Addy, 2011. Toward a general theory of evolution: Extending Darwinian theory to inanimate matter. Journal of Systems Chemistry [online]. 7.6., roč. 2, č. 1, s. 1 [vid. 3. září 2014]. ISSN 1759-2208. Dostupné z: doi:10.1186/1759-2208-2-1

PROSS, Addy, 2014. What is Life?: How Chemistry Becomes Biology. Reprint edition. B.m.: Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780199687770.

PROTHERO, Donald R., 2013. Reality Check: How Science Deniers Threaten Our Future. Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press. ISBN 9780253010292.

ROSENBERG, Alex, 2011. The Atheist’s Guide to Reality: Enjoying Life without Illusions. 1st edition. New York: W. W. Norton & Company. ISBN 9780393080230.

ROSENBERG, Alex, 2014. How physics fakes design. In: Paul R. THOMPSON a Denis WALSH, ed. Evolutionary Biology: Conceptual, Ethical, and Religious Issues. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, s. 217–238.

RUSE, Michael, 2007. Philosophy of Biology. 2nd edition. Amherst, N.Y: Prometheus Books. ISBN 9781591025276.

RUSSELL, Peter J. a Paul E. HERTZ, 2013. Biology: The Dynamic Science. 3rd edition. Belmont, CA: Cengage Learning. ISBN 9781133587552.

SADAVA, David E., David M. HILLIS, H. Craig HELLER a May BERENBAUM, 2009. Life: The Science of Biology. 9th edition. Sunderland, Mass. : Gordonsville, Va: W. H. Freeman. ISBN 9781429219624.

SARKAR, Sahotra, 2010. A Companion to the Philosophy of Biology. 1st edition. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell. ISBN 9781444337853.

SCHÄFER, E. A., 1912. The Nature, Origin and Maintenance of Life. Science. roč. 36, č. 923, s. 289–312.

SOBER, Elliott, 1990. Learning from Functionalism - Prospects for Strong Artificial Life. In: Christopher G. LANGTON, Charles TAYLOR, J. Doyne FARMER a Steen RASMUSSEN, ed.Artificial Life II. Proceedings of the Workshop on Artificial Life Held February, 1990 in Santa Fe, New Mexico. Santa Fe Institute: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company.

STERN, Alan, 2010. Alan Stern: ‘A Chihuahua is still a dog, and Pluto is still a planet’ | EarthSky.org [online] [vid. 2. září 2014]. Dostupné z: http://earthsky.org/space/alan-stern-%e2%80%98a-chihuahua-is-still-a-dog-and-pluto-is-still-a-planet-2

SWEETLOVE, Lee, 2011. Number of species on Earth tagged at 8.7 million. Nature News [online]. 23.8. [vid. 3. září 2014]. ISSN 0028-0836. Dostupné z: doi:10.1038/news.2011.498

TRIFONOV, Edward N., 2011. Vocabulary of definitions of life suggests a definition. Journal of Biomolecular Structure & Dynamics [online]. 10., roč. 29, č. 2, s. 259–266. ISSN 1538-0254. Dostupné z: doi:10.1080/073911011010524992

WEBER, Bruce, 2014. Life. In: Edward N. ZALTA, ed. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy [online]. Fall 2014. [vid. 31. srpen 2014]. Dostupné z: http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2014/entries/life/

WINGO, Walter, 1963. Definition of Life. The Science News-Letter [online]. 7.9., roč. 84, č. 10, s. 147 [vid. 3. září 2014]. ISSN 00964018. Dostupné z: doi:10.2307/3946580





Published by the Department of Philosophy, Faculty of Arts, Masaryk University, Brno, Czech Republic.
ISSN: 1212-9097