Two forms of punishment in Plato's dialogue Gorgias

Anežka Chovanková

Abstract


The article is dedicated to the problem of myth at the end of the dialogue Gorgias in connection with the function of punishment in Plato´s dialogues. Gorgias is one of the dialogues that are crucial for understanding of the problem of punishment. It may seem that focusing on final eschatological myth, author holds ambiguous view in connection with given questions. There is a contradiction at the level mythoslogos: on the one hand, a remedial purpose of punishment is presented  in the whole dialogue. However, there is a switch at the end and Plato´s eschatological myth presents a view that is distinct at the first sight. Is it possible that a myth opposes Plato´s thesis of remedial purpose of punishment and its retributive character comes to the fore? Otherwise, there is no contradiction at all and particular elements of dialogue fit. The aim of the article is to demonstrate that a change of view on form of punishment and considering punishment as a method elenchos could be the key to understand the relation of mythoslogos in the given dialogue.

Keywords


Plato, Gorgias, punishment, elenchos, mythos, logos

https://doi.org/10.5817/pf15-2-1034

Full Text:

PDF (Czech)

References

Show references Hide references

ANNAS, J. (1982): Plato’s Myth of Judgement. Phronesis. Vol. 27, No. 2, pp. 119-143.

BENSON, H. (1987): The Problem of the Elenchus Reconsidered. Ancient Philosophy. Vol. 7, pp. 67-85.

BRISSON, L. (2000): Plato the Myth Maker. Translated by G. Naddaf, Chicago: University of Chiccago Press.

DANIELS, Ch. B. (1992): The Afterlife Myth in Plato’s Gorgias. The Journal of Value Inquiry. Vol. 26, No. 2, pp. 271-279.

DODDS, E. R. (1959): Plato. Gorgias. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

EDELSTEIN, L. (1949): The Function of the Myth in Plato’s Philosophy. Journal of the History of Ideas. Vol 10, No 4, pp. 463-481.

EDMONDS, R. G. (2012): Whip Scars on the Naked Soul: Myth and Elenchos in Plato’s Gorgias. In: COLLOBERT, C. – DESTRÉE, P. – GONZALES, F. J. (eds): Plato and Myth. Leiden/Boston: Brill, pp. 165-186.

GREGORY, M. J. (1968): Myth and Transcendence in Plato. Thought. Vol. 43, pp. 273-296.

MACKENZIE, M. M. (1981): Plato on punishment. Berkeley: University of California Press.

PLATÓN (1961): Zákony. Praha: NČSAV. (skratka Leg.)

PLATÓN (2000): Gorgias. Praha: OIKOYMENH.

PLATÓN (2000): Prótagoras. Praha: OIKOYMENH. (skratka Protg.)

ROWE, Ch. (2012): The Status of the Myth of the Gorgias, or: Taking Plato Seriously. In: COLLOBERT, C – DESTRÉE, P. – GONZALES, F. J. (eds): Plato and Myth. Leiden/Boston: Brill, pp. 187-198.

SAUNDERS, T. J. (1991): Plato’s Penal Code. Oxford: Claredon Press.

SEDLEY, D. (2009): Myth, Punishment and Politics in Plato’s Gorgias. In: PARTENIE, C. (ed): Plato’s Myth. Cambridge/New York: Cambridge Universtiy Press, pp. 51-76.

STORMER, G. (1974): Plato’s Theory of Myth. The Personalist. Vol. 55, pp. 216-223.

TARNOPOLSKY, H. K. (2010): Prudes, Preverts, and Tyrants. Plato’s Gorgias and the Politics of Shame. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

VLASTOS, G. (1983): The Socratic Elenchus. Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy. Vol. 1, pp. 27-58.





Published by the Department of Philosophy, Faculty of Arts, Masaryk University, Brno, Czech Republic.
ISSN: 1212-9097